K Johnson/Pelfrey for Beckham/Feliz

[changho515]

Kelly Johnson and Mike Pelfrey

for

Gordon Beckham and Neftali Feliz


Is this a fair trade? Who gets the better end of it?

[saemick]

tough to know without seeing the rest of your roster

[changho515]

12team 5x5 redraft.

C-McCann C-Santana
1B-Fielder CI-Morneau
2B-Weeks MI-K.Johnson (trade) Beckham (trade for)
3B-C. Jones
SS-Peralta DL-Y.Escobar DL-JJ Hardy
OF-Sizemore OF-Hamilton OF-Bruce OF-Rasmus OF-D.Young UT-Willingham

SP-Haren SP-Hanson SP-Baker SP-Niemann SP-Zito SP-Slowey SP-Pelfrey (trade)

RP-Soria RP-Francisco RP-Wood RP-C.Perez RP-Feliz (trade for)

[teaaker]

I don't like Beckham much this year. That being said, Pelfrey is almost replacement level on the waivers, Johnson's power came out of no where. You don't need another closer, so I don't do it.

[saemick]

I don't really see this being an upgrade for you. You're fine at the closer position and I really don't know if Beckham is gonna come out of this funk anytime soon. As for Johnson, he had the potential in Atlanta, but just couldn't put it together. I had him pegged as one of my sleeper 2B's as many others did, so while the amount of HR's might be a surprise, I don't really see him taking a hit in the other categories

thanks for helping with mine

[wyld stallions]

I think I would stay put. This does not improve your team.

thx for help in mine

[miracles716]

my opinion pelf is average nothing special, beckham is going through a sophmore slump and doesnt look to get out if it so it goes down to feliz and johnson and my thinking is closers are easy to get and johnson is having a monster tyear so dont do the deal, help me with mine
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=411823

[LARS929]

I do the deal for the simple reason that you aren't playing Johnson anyways so he doesn't help you out. The deal seems to be 3 guys who are useless for you in exchange for a closer. Do it, but really this trade is one I see no reason for doing because of the low talent level of everyone in the trade

viewtopic.php?t=411845