Cliff Lee/McCutchen for Justin Upton *WHIR*

[teaaker]

I would be giving Mccutchen and Cliff Lee for Justin Upton in a Keeper League that has a regular 5x5 league with OBP and doubles added for hitting, QS and K/9 for pitching.

C Kurt Suzuki
1b Prince Fielder
2b Uggla
3b Longoria
ss Hanley Ramirez
MI Ricky Weeks
CI Miggy Cabrera
OF Kemp
OF Jason Bay
OF Andrew Mccutchen
OF J.D. Drew
UTIL Votto

BN: Stanton

Sp Lester
Sp Nolasco
Sp Wainwright
P C. Lee
P Wade Davis
P Kuroda
P Lackey
P Bucholtz
P Colby Lewis
P C.J. Wilson
Rp Broxton
Rp Jenks
Rp Lindstrom
DL Bedard

[LARS929]

It is good for you for the future, but may hurt you this year. Also you might have too many keepers

[Celtics31]

I would do it. Upton seems like too much talent to pass up on.

[CubsFan4Life23]

It's a good deal, but all depends on how many you keep each year.

[guyincognito]

I'm struggling with something similar, but your pitching is a little deeper then mine, so you can afford to part with Lee. I would make the deal. Although the previous poster brings up a good point. How many keepers are you hanging onto, because if it's only like 5 players, I'm not sure he makes your list in which case it might not be worth it for you.

Help me?: viewtopic.php?f=26&t=411799

[changho515]

I'd keep Lee and McCutchen. I think Upton is going to be a stud, but I think McCutchen will be very good as well and Lee is nails.

viewtopic.php?t=411803

[skjelstrom]

Upton is definitely the better player of the future so I do like this deal, but it depends on whether you think you can win this year even with giving up Lee and McCutchen. It also depends on how many your allowed to keep each year.

Overall I do like this deal as he should heat up this year, and be solid for the future also.

[teaaker]

We do keep 8 each year, he is definitely on my list. I wouldn't keep Lee (Keeping Wainwright and Lester).