rank these closers in order

[miracles716]

keeper league, can keep 12 players, trying to decide which closers to keep, have 6, they are marmol, bell, bailey, aardsma, franklin and hoffman, please analyze and rank them in order from first to last, thank you

[Bferryvt]

marmol, bell, bailey, aardsma, franklin and hoffman....

Without looking, I think it's Bell, Franklin, Bailey, Marmol, Aardsma. PERIOD.

[miracles716]

i think franklin is combustible and u dont think marmol and his 38ks should be #1?

[miracles716]

bump

[Bferryvt]

It was without looking, my teams have scrap heaps for closers so I'm probably not the best expert to pick on the subject. I've had Marmol, I've never trusted him enough to vault him to number 1 I don't think, but others may disagree. I still think I take Bell #1

[bazzy_51]

Bell-undisputed #1 on your roster.

Bailey-A's aren't very good, but will get plent of save opps and gave up his first ER of the year today in his 13th appearence
Marmol-Won't get as many save opps as the first 2, but will be a great source of RP Ks, and should have good ratios to boot.

Franklin-I think its only going to be time before he really implodes and ends up losing the job, but the only thing keeping him this high is he still has the job and plays for the Cards.
Hoffman-Had a rough patch and got through it, not it seems to be clear sailing from here.


Aardsma-Have almost no faith in him, and is a liability as a closer. His ratios will continue to climb as will his Losses and blown saves go hand in hand. Weakest of your 6 imo.