Halladay Trade Help!

[mmeye19]

4 Team League, 5x5 Roto, the trade is Roy Halladay for Andre Ethier and B.J. Upton.

Here's my team:
C Brian McCann, SP Roy Halladay
1B Justin Morneau, SP Tim Lincecum
2B Ben Zobrist, SP Felix Hernandez
3B Ryan Zimmerman, SP Zach Greinke
SS Hanley Ramirez, SP Dan Haren
2B/SS Kelly Johnson, RP Mariano Rivera
1B/3B Billy Butler, RP Jonathan Papelbon
OF Carl Crawford, P Johan Santana
OF Justin Upton, P Joakim Soria
OF Jason Bay, P Matt Capps
OF Bobby Abreu, Bench Clayton Kershaw
OF Shin Soo Choo, Bench James Shields
UTIL Hunter Pence, Bench Yovani Gallardo
UTIL Alex Rios
UTIL Michael Bourn
UTIL Colby Rasmus
UTIL Vladimir Guerrero
Bench Aramis Ramirez
Bench Jay Bruce
DL Jimmy Rollins
DL Carlos Beltran

Please help! Thanks!

[mmeye19]

bump

[baegames]

In a 4 team league, Upton is essentially waiver wire material, so the trade is Halladay for Ethier. Pass. I would consider it in a bigger league, but not here.

Help with mine:

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=411740

[mmeye19]

thanks a bunch! anyone else have an opinion?!

[bosoxrock34]

im goin with the theory of upton would be ww too. so halladay for ethier i dont think i do. I value halladay equal to lincecum. lincecum will have more ks but halladay will have the wins.

some help
viewtopic.php?t=411836&hilit=braun