I also look to get the best player in the deal, but you are giving too much up in terms of your roster value.
you would go from: 3B-Zimmy, UTIL-McGehee, SP1-2-3: Ubaldo-Verlander-Hamels to 3B-McGehee, Util-Howard, SP1-2-3: Ubaldo-Gallardo-Davis.
I think your squad loses too much, seens how you already have a very nice 1B (yes not Howard power numbers, but I would rather a top 5 3B like Zimmy over starting McGehee who has a solid shot of fading) and its not worth ripping your SP apart to get another 1B. I love your 1-2-3 now, and not a believer in Gallardo over Verlander and I have a hard time saying I like Yovani better then Cole either. Very nice deal value wise, but I think your team hurts too much by losing that much talent just to get another big bat.
Help me out...viewtopic.php?t=411580