Is this proposed trade fair? WHIR

[kingdon22]

I am dead last in nearly every offensive category in a 12 tam H2H...

But this guy just traded Mauer for a 2b, so he may need a Catcher...and I am overvaluing my players?

I would be trading Victor Martinez, Chone Figgins, and Hunter Pence for Mark Reynolds, Yadier Molina, and Carl Crawford.

If I am overvaluing here is my roster maybe you can come up with something more realistic that would get accepted.

C-Victor Martinez
1B-Ryan Howard
2b-Ian Kinseler
3B-Michael Young
SS-Miguel Tejada
OF-Jayson Werth
OF-Andre Ethier
OF-Michael Bourn
Utl-Hunter Pence
Utl-Chone Figgins
Bench- Mike Aviles
Bench- Martin Prado
Bench Juan Pierre

I need every offensive category ...mainly runs, hr, rbi...just not SB.

[Dodgerblue8188]

I'm surprised your dead last in so many categories. Maybe just sit tight and see what happens. Some of those players maybe having a slow start and could start playing better.

[Wiserman20]

I don't think the other guy will bite on that but go ahead and try if you think you can pull it off..

I do think you're overvaluing.. Reynolds hit 44 jacks last year and almost 30 in '08...Crawford swiped 60 bags last year amongst other things and is playing for a big time contract next year..

Unless I'm missing something.. I'm not sure what the other guy gains outside of a HR upgrade at catcher? Yadier is leading all Catchers in points currently in my league (probably becuase he's swiped 4 bags)..

[harold_bush]

Yeah, unfortuantely you are very much overvaluing your guys. FIggins and Pence are basically throw away players in my opinion, they offer very little value. VMart is a player, but you are basically asking this guy to trade a 1st/2nd round talent in Crawford, a 3rd/4th round pick in Reynolds, for a 4th/5th round pick in VMart. He has a net loss in every single offensive category in this deal.