Standard H2H 5x5 12 Man League C- Matt Wieters 1B-Todd Helton 2B-Ian Stewart 3B-Ryan Zimmerman SS-Hanley Ramirez OF-Jason Heyward OF-BJ Upton OF-Sin-Soo Choo UTIL- Carlos Quentin BN- Adam Jones
Im tired of holding onto adam jones and carlos quentin riding my bench, which one should i drop and for what WW player to replace them. My teams weak points are runs, sbs, and BA: Pierre Headley Guillen
With the three available, Pierre is the most sure thing in terms of knowing what you'll get, and SBs from him will at times win the SB category all by himself. My next choice would be Guillen, but I'd probably go Pierre, keep him on the bench, and if you're 1 SB down with three games to go in the weekly matchup, throw him in and try to "steal" that cat.
I agree that you should stand. I also agree that Pierre is the best long-term option out of those listed. If you truly are frustrated at your slumping players, however, I don't know why you'd dump one slumping player with a higher upside for another (Pierre's BA is atrocious right now). Go with Guillen if you're really trying to ride the hot hand, but really, just stay put.