Holliday for Zito/R. Soriano

[BigBob1989]

12 man h2h.. My pitching is a little weak but I'm high on Holliday. I'd be giving up Holliday for Barry Zito and Rafeal Soriano. What would you do?

[soty]

Without seeing the rest of your team just on value alone I like this deal. Holliday is a stud OF and who really knows whats going on with Zito? Even if he stays like this the rest of the year (which I don't think he does) then Holliday is still a much better option. Plus I always take the batter over the pitcher.

[michaelyoung4prez]

Really, I say H No

[The Artful Dodger]

That's too little for Holliday. You should get an established #1 ace in lieu of Zito (let's say Greinke, Sabathia, perhaps Halladay).