Sheilds Trade? WHIR

[TheIceman]

Alright I'm wondering what you guys think of this trade....I'd be giving Shields (P) for Kinsler and Adam Jones....what are your thoughts?

Here's my lineup to better help you out:

L. Marson C
V. Martinez C BOS 2
D. Lee 1B
C. Barmes 2B
A. Beltre 3B
D. Jeter SS
J. Reyes MI
N. Swisher CI
B. Abreu OF
A. Kearns OF
R. Ludwick OF
I. Suzuki OF
C. Gonzalez U
J. Broxton P
F. Cordero P
J. Duchscherer P
R. Halladay P
S. Kazmir P
C. Kershaw P
D. Matsuzaka P
B. Penny P
J. Shields P
R. Wells P


Reserves
A. Callaspo MI
C. Beltran OF
M. Bradley OF
D. Ackley U
T. Glaus U
R. Ibanez

J. Montero U
C. Santana U
S. Strasburg P
C. Young P

[TheIceman]

I'm in a 5X5 roto league as well and sitting in 8th place.

[KJROD20]

this seems like a no brainer. You need help at 2nd desperately and Kinsler is one of the best at his position.

help?
viewtopic.php?t=410811

[harold_bush]

Shields is a nice pitcher, but you absolutley have to do this deal. I'd easily trade Shields staright up for Kinsler, and if you get the upside of Adam Jones it makes it even easier. Yes please.

viewtopic.php?t=410847