Please Help With This Big Trade **WHIR**

[Da Rook]

IDo you think I should make this deal in my standard 5X5 non-keeper league...and why?

I was offered:

Arod
D. Pedroia
C. Quinten
R. Ludwick
J. Jurrjins

for

D. Wright
R. Weeks
M. Holiday
P. Konerko
R. Harden



LEAVE LINK - WILL HELP IN RETUN!!!

[rdsoxfan58]

I think I pass this year. If it was 2008- sure I'd do it

Arod < D Wright (Younger and healthier- and I have Arod on my team)
D. Pedroia > Weeks
C. Quinten < Holliday (struggling but still better than those 2 OFs)
R. Ludwick < Konerko- can he keep it up? Probably not but at least he's hitting
J. Jurrjins < Harden is at least playing and healthy


So Pedroia is really the only upgrade here unless you think Arod explodes at some point in the season.

Who is he targeting in the trade?

[Hamburglar07]

I strongly disagree about Wright being better than A-rod... A-rod is having a cold start while Wright is starting off well, but it's undeniable that Rodriguez is the much better player, not to mention he had a better year last year.

I traded Wright and Vlad for Arod so I would hope he gets better.

That being said... I still don't think Id make this trade. Holliday will heat it up and everday Konerko is making his hot start seem like less of a fluke. Jurjens and Harden to me are about equally mediocre.