Lopez and Ramirez For Reyes

[bondfast12]

Got offered Jose Lopez and Aramis Ramirez for Jose Reyes.

My team:

C- Yadier Molina
1b - miguel cabrera
2b - casey mcgehee
ss - jose reyes / ryan theriot
3b - scott rolen
of - matt kemp, carl crawford, juan rivera
util - lance berkman, hideki matsui, mike napoli

any thoughts?

[Kimbos Beard]

Hate that deal for you. You would be selling really really low on Reyes. I am sure you could get much more back than that.

Mine: viewtopic.php?f=26&t=410802

[askretzinger]

I agree with Kimbos Beard...Ramirez is an upgrade at third but not enough to get rid of Reyes. Reyes has started out slow but you have to remember he is still trying to get back into the swing of baseball being out for spring training and most of last season. He'll be alright and back to posting solid Reyes-like numbers before too long and you'll wish you had kept him. Besides that I like McGehee more at 2nd than Lopez. I would stay with Reyes or ask for top talent in return.