Longo/Upton/Fielder/Morales 3 team deal, WHIR

[Alexs]

I'd be getting the players from Team C: I'd be giving up Longo, Morales, Matusz, Guillen.
Currently I have votto and morales at 1b so prince would be my util instead of morales, but mccutchen is an upgrade over guillen. I'd be putting casey mcgahee in for longo....

I'm hesitent and dont think its a great deal for me, but i really like longoria. Is this a good or bad deal for me? It's the standard 5x5 plus OPS, H, TB,BB and L, CG,SHO, QS

Team A:
Justin Upton
Kendry Morales
Brian Matusz

Team B:
Evan Longoria
Jose Guillen
Adam Lind

Team C:
Prince Fielder
Clayton Kershaw
Andrew McCutchen

[Dave8603]

Thanks for the help. I don't think this is a good deal for you. If I understand this right, you would be giving up Longoria, Morales, Matusz, Guillen, getting back Fielder, Kershaw and McCutchen and Upton and Lind go to some other team? I think that's giving up way too much. Morales might not reach last year's totals but I think Matusz has the potential to match Kershaw this year and then you are basically giving up Longoria, Morales and Guillen for Fielder and McCutchen. There's just no reason to do that.

[Alexs]

*bump* any other opinions?