Trade offer: let me know what you guys think

[go9ers]

I got offered a trade - other team didn't draft a 1B until late. Trade is I give Morneau/Lilly for his Victorino/C.Lee. This is a 10 team h2h points league (4pts for homer, 3 for triple, 2 for double, 1 for single, r, rbi, bb and no deduction for avg or k's) (10pts for W, -5 for L, 7pt for save, 1 pt per strikeout and IP, -1 per ER).

My team:
C: RMartin
1B: Fielder
2B: Polanco
3B: Reynolds
SS: A.Cabrera
IF: Morneau
OF: Bay, MKemp, Choo
UT: Laroche
Bench: Hawpe, Roberts (IR)

SP (4 starters per week): Hamels, Wainwright, Baker, Nolasco
RP: (2 per week): Bell, Valverde
Bench: Garcia, BWilson, Porcello, Blanton, Lilly, Danks, Latos

His team:
C: McCann
1B: Cantu
2B: Utley
3B: Beltre
SS:Uribe
IF: Freese
OF: Suzuki, Victorino, Bryd
UT: Damon
Bench: Granderson, Rollins, Aybar, Gutierrez

SP: Lincecum, Lee, Harden, Shields
RP: Broxton, Rivera
Bench: Lackey, Duchscherer, Pavano, Hochevar, Willis

[Dave8603]

Your team seems stacked with power and in a league that favors home runs, that's a good thing. The best player here is Morneau. Victorino is a close second though. Lilly is a capable starter but you don't really need him. Carlos Lee is a complete wildcard. I have him in two leagues and he's killing me right now. Even if he does pick it up, he's still not going to reach Morneau's numbers. And with the way he's playing, I'm not even sure he does pick it up. So as it stands, you would be trading Morneau and Lilly for Victorino in a league that rewards home runs. I think I would pass on this trade.

Please help me out:
viewtopic.php?t=410740

[go9ers]

Sorry for any confusion...it's Cliff Lee, not Carlos.

[chowder]

bump...WHIR

[pizzaboy76]

I like this trade for you. With Bay not producing you need OF help.

Please help;

viewtopic.php?t=410804

[chowder]

one more bump...I need to accept or reject this trade by early afternoon today. Please let me know any more thoughts on this one - WHIR.