Am I Giving Up Too Much?

[rasto21585]

In my 20 team h2h dynasty league I was offered miguel cabrera and jaime garcia for bj upton cole hamels and jesus montero. On paper this looks like a steal but i don't know if my team will remain competitive after losing hamels. Also is it too much since i am including a stud prospect in jesus montero? What should I do?

Batters Stat Categories: Runs (R), Home Runs (HR), Runs Batted In (RBI), Stolen Bases (SB), Batting Average (AVG), On-base + Slugging Percentage (OPS)
Pitchers Stat Categories: Wins (W), Saves (SV), Strikeouts (K), Holds (HLD), Earned Run Average (ERA), (Walks + Hits)/ Innings Pitched (WHIP)


20 team h2h dynasty league

c russel martin
1b justin morneau
2b howie kendrick
3b chase headly
ss ryan theriot
if blake dewitt
lf carlos lee
cf colby rasmus
rf justin upton
of ryan ludwick
util bj upton
bn fucodome
bn jesus montero
bn alex avila

sp jon lester
sp cole hamels
sp colby lewis
rp rafael soriano
rp cj wilson
rp dustin nippert
p ryan rowland smith
p jason motte
p mike leake
bn homer bailey
bn charlie haegar
bn geo gonzalez
dj jose mijares

[rasto21585]

bump please

[LampShade3]

Well u have a decent catcher already so its not as if u would be hurting yourself too terribly by dealing Montero. Id take Miggy over BJ and its not close and Garcis looks like hes gonna outpitch Hamels. In my opinion its worth it to take the Miggy side.

[rasto21585]

anyone else

[gogogadget]

I agree with previous post. I think Garcia has a higher upside than Hamels at this point. I don't think Cole will live up to the optimistic hype he initially attracted. While Garcia will help you win this year and for years to come. Not to mention you are getting a proven Miguel Cabrera, who will be a top 5 firstbaseman for a couple more years at least.

[soty]

I like it for you I would pull the trigger.

Help Me
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=410682

[rasto21585]

bump

[silverlionlb]

I like the deal for you. Cabrera is excellent value in a dynasty and should be an offensive anchor in your infield for years. Garcia has a lot of upside as well. I'm not ready to completely give up on Hamels, but for Cabrera, that's a trade off I'd be willing to take. You lose a prospect, but Martin is still nothing to sneeze at in the C position, even with his current slump. I say take it.

Mine: viewtopic.php?t=410701

[rasto21585]

Do you think this is a fair deal for both sides? My league is veto happy and I hope this trade will not get shutdown.

[gogogadget]

I think it is a trade in your favor, but its one of those things I would never veto. There is no reason not to give it a shot.