Cole Hamels/Jake Peavy for Matt Holliday/Chad Qualls WHIR

[threelions]

We were chatting and whining, talking about junk for junk trade ideas, and surfaced this trade.

any thoughts?

leave a link, WHIR

[bazzy_51]

I really like that deal, but looking at your roster I don't think you have enough SP fire power to do it.

I'd love to get the big bat and potentially the best player in the deal, but as much as it would help adding a big bat at a fairly reasonable price, it would just hurt your starting staff more losing your ace. If Anderson were back healthy tomorrow then I would rethink this deal and probably take it, but with him injured your really looking at Jaime Garcia as your ace if you do it now.

Sorry, hard to say, but I'd pass for now.