Teixeira for BJ Upton (or Holliday) + Billy Butler? WHIR.

[bloc8888]

I'm in a 10-person, CBS points-based dynasty league.
We keep 22 each year (out of a roster of 32), so it's very very deep.
Scoring is: H=1, BB=1, 2B=1, 3b=2, HR=3, RBI=1, SB=1, R=1, CS=-1, KO=-1

I currently own Teixeira, and am debating giving him up for some combination of CI + outfielder ... I have been offered BJ Upton + Billy Butler for Teixeira. I like BJ, especially for a dynasty league, but am I giving up too much for Tex? I considered countering with Holliday + Butler for Tex... One concern -- we have no Util/DH spot, so if Butler becomes a DH and loses 1B eligibility a few years down the road, he becomes useless to me. The other guy also has Ian Stewart, and I bet I could get him to give me Stewart+BJ+Butler, for Tex+Cantu.

Thoughts?
I will help those in return... My team is below:

Suzuki, Kurt C
Teixeira, Mark 1B
Beckham, Gordon 2B
Wright, David 3B
Tulowitzki, Troy SS
Cantu, Jorge CI
Bruce, Jay OF
Gutierrez, Franklin OF
Rios, Alex OF
Upton, Justin OF

Hanson, Tommy SP
Kershaw, Clayton SP
Lee, Cliff SP
Sanchez, Jonathan O. SP
Weaver, Jered SP

Franklin, Ryan RP
Wilson, Brian RP

RESERVES
Saltalamacchia, Jarrod C
Wallace, Brett 3B
Ellsbury, Jacoby CF
Jennings, Desmond CF
Stubbs, Drew CF
Taylor, Michael LF

Buchholz, Clay SP
Kennedy, Ian SP
Niemann, Jeff SP
Scheppers, Tanner SP
Webb, Brandon SP
Chacin, Jhoulys SP
Wilson, C.J. SP
Motte, Jason RP
Francisco, Frank RP

[shoof08]

Thanks for the help on mine. For a guy like Tex I think you need to go for a 3 for 1 if you're looking to trade him. He is in his prime hitting wise plus he plays half his games in a hitters friendly park. I'd look to trade for a C+Cl+OF/1B. Your outfield situation is very good and is plus for your team. Although they are no top of the line starters they are very solid and relatively young.