kelly johnson for jake peavy. which one you want

[ghosty]

kell johnson for jake peavy . what side of the trade would you want

[RowdyRed]

Roster and settings?

My gut says Peavy. This is a classic buy low, sell high. I bet these two wind up with roughly equal value on the year by the end of the season, and neither is going to be tremendous, but that means that Peavy will be more valuable over the rest of the season.