Rank these 5 IF options - WHIR

[Captain Furtah]

Here is how I have them, what about you?

E Young Jr.
I Desmond (added bonus for dual position)
Freese
Brignac (added bonus for dual position)
Pennington
Rolen


I just traded Figgins and need another IF. Here is my roster;

C-McCann
1B- D Lee, Ad LaRoche, J Lopez
2B- J Lopez,
SS- Tulowitszki
3B- A Ramirez, Beltre, J Lopez
IF-
LF- Lind, Choo, Borbon
CF- McCutchen, Borbon
RF- Choo, Bruce
OF-
UT-

SP- Lincecum, Gallardo, Nolasco, Billingsly, Scherzer, Chapman, Anderson
RP- Cordero, Bailey, Qualls, J Gutierrez

post a link and I WHIR

[Wadderboiz]

Looks like you have plenty of stable vets, taking a flier on a youngster might not be a bad idea...

Young
Freese
Desmond
Rolen
Pennington
Brignac

[footballisbetter.com]

Looks like you have plenty of stable vets, taking a flier on a youngster might not be a bad idea...

Young
Freese
Desmond
Rolen
Pennington
Brignac

I agree. If Young can keep a regular spot in the lineup, he is the guy I would want.

[RowdyRed]

I would put Desmond in second, but other than that, I agree. I would take Young at this point.

[Captain Furtah]

I only get 20 moves (have already used 3), so if I do pick up E Young Jr. it is critical for me that he stays in the majors (but I guess there is some risk with Stewart too...)

[bloc8888]

Here's how I would have 'em:

E Young Jr.
I Desmond (added bonus for dual position)
Freese
Rolen
Brignac (added bonus for dual position)
Pennington

Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?t=410447