Big Trade WHIR

[eviljoshing]

14 team Roto

Would you trade a-rod, lidge and jurrgens for dan haren, nelson cruz and soria? I feel like it's a no brainer but Cruz's injury is a bit worrisome. Thoughts?

[jmlevy]

I see it like this:

Soria >> Lidge
Haren >> Jurrjens
Cruz < ARod

Cruz has the potential and youth to match ARod's studly status, but his injury gives me some cause for concern. If you have a backup 3B and power to hold off without Cruz for the time being, I think you pull the trigger.

[sadlyajetsfan]

It's worth it. Cruz looked amazing and always has minor injuries. This shouldn't be too big of an issue for him, still a top OF. You're making huge upgrades at SP and RP. Haren will really add a ton to your team compared to Jurr. Do you have a serviceable 3B? That would be my only concern.

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=410330
please help

[rukus9]

I would do that in a heartbeat. ARod and Cruz are a wash and Haren/Soria > Jurrjens/Lidge.

[eviljoshing]

I already have a great 3B in Reynolds. I actually could use the help at OF and was interested to see what people were reading into Cruz's recent hammy issues.

[espnsportsfan]

Cruz's injury seems like a quick thing...plus the upside of the other 2 is too great not to do this deal

[rukus9]

He was supposed going to start taking BP on Saturday so hopefully he will be back on schedule.

[BigDunn]

With Reynolds, this is a definite yes. Go accept it now.

Help with mine: viewtopic.php?f=26&t=410336

[NikkiSixx]

Well if you have Mark Reynolds then what are you waiting for! Definitely do this trade.


Thanks for the help on mine.