granderson/abreu/peavy for r.davis/ludwick/strasburg WHIR!!!

[rolen187]

10 team keeper league, 7x7 cats, classic 5x5 plus CG, QS, and OPS and 2B

i was offered granderson/abreu/peavy

for my:

r.davis/ludwick/strasburg

here is my roster

C Jorge Posada
1B Miguel Cabrera
2B Casey McGehee
3B Jorge Cantú
SS Miguel Tejada
LF Adam Dunn
CF Rajai Davis
RF Ryan Ludwick
Util Álex Rodríguez
Util Billy Butler
BN José Guillén
BN Jason Bay
BN Miguel Olivo
DL Ian Kinsler

SP Cliff Lee
SP Ubaldo Jiménez
SP Randy Wolf
RP Carlos Mármol
RP José Valverde
P Octavio Dotel
P Dallas Braden
P Ben Sheets
BN Jon Rauch
BN Carlos Zambrano
BN Stephen Strasburg


i would love to take this but hate having to give up stras in a keeper league! let me know what you guys think....WHIR

[Dragonz]

Since its a keeper league, I would want someone other than Peavy. IMO

[bazzy_51]

How many keepers are you alotted to keep? Because if its only like 4-5 I think I would do this deal for the simple fact that in a keeper with that small a number of keepers that makes Grandy and even Abrue the 2 best players in that deal. Rajai Davis is only good for SB, and his average is junk thus far and Abrue holds more value then Davis, Ludwick has power, but hasn't been putting it together and I like the odds of Grandy hitting 30HR and swiping 20bags over Ludwick hitting 35HR again.

Again if this is a league where you only keep 4-5 or less I do it. Heck even if you keep 7-8 I gotta think I would do it still as I see your top 7 as it stands now as:
Miggy
Arod
Butler
Bay
Kinsler
Cliff Lee
Ubaldo

And in this trade if you do it I see Grandy as your 8th best player and even Dunn as your 9th best. Stras may be your 9th-10th best player either way so. Again if its a whole roster keeper I would think a bit more about and try to get a better SP then Peavy, if you keep any number un 8 then I do the deal.

[Seanyfever]

Despite the keeper, I want the most potential now. Granderson side for me.

Lend your voice & opinion to me????
viewtopic.php?t=410198

[LampShade3]

Granderson side and I dont think its even close.