huge trade

[sworley3]

i send lind, berkman and cc and i get pujols and kelly johnson. should i do it?

[Fantasy GM]

If Berkman was fully healthy, I'd pass. However, the fact he's still hurting makes this trade questionable. Having said that, I still say pass.

Lind is a very good OF, Berkman healthy can produce, and CC is an ace. Pujols is beyond great, but I feel Kelly Johnson cools down soon. Maybe he'll be 2010's Aaron Hill, maybe not.

How's this huge trade? viewtopic.php?f=26&t=410103

[sworley3]

what if i said that i have halladay, oswalt, felix and zito all on my roster already. does that change anything?

[Fantasy GM]

Who do you have at 1B and 2B?

[sworley3]

1b - berkman
2b - either wigginton, mcgehee, polanco or kinsler (i use these guys for multiple positions since all but kinsler have that eligibility)

[Fantasy GM]

If Berkman is still gimpy, may as well pull the trade. If he's healthy, you have good 2B as it is (Kinsler in particular when he's playing and also Polanco/McGehee) that you'll be ok.