Zimmerman/A. Jones for Sizemore/Billingsley?

[jordan9148]

14 team standard H2H league. year two of 3 year keeper league. just got offered this trade, with me giving up zimmerman and jones. am i giving up too much in this deal? any advice is appreciated
thanks and leace a link...
My team
C- c snyder
1B- P. Fielder
2b- H. Kendrick
SS- Tulo
3B- Zimmerman
OF- crawford
OF- adam jones
OF- chris young
UTIL- nyger morgan
Bench -austin jackson

SP- Cain
SP-J. Santana
SP- Jurrjens
SP- Cueto
SP- Harden
SP-wade davis
SP-scherzer
RP Aardsma
RP- Street
RP- Qualls

[thejusman1]

Boy, that's tough. I think Grady Sizemore is an excellent buy-low right now. He's not that far removed from a 30/30 campaign season, and while he looks plain awful right now, you have to think that kind of talent isn't a fluke. Billingsley walks too many batters for my liking, but he can resemble an ace, like in the first half of last year, and is still young and developing. I would lean towards accepting this trade, but who would you have to slide in to 3B if you ship out Zimmerman? I'm not a fan of creating gaping holes, and if you don't have someone ready to fill the vacancy I would stand pat.

[jordan9148]

free agent 3B are pretty thin
scott rolen
mark teahen
alex gordon
aybar
inge

[thejusman1]

I would hold then. 3B is too shallow in your league to make that leap of faith with Sizemore.

[rukus9]

I would stay put. Jones and Sizemore are a wash to me at this point and Zimmerman > Billingsley.