UTLEY for Sizemore, Morneau, and R.Soriano

[enyouartist]

I would be getting Utley. Is this a good deal for me, or would I be giving up too much?

C Kurt Suzuki
1B Justin Morneau
2B Robinson Canó
3B David Wright
SS José Reyes
OF Andre Ethier
OF Ryan Braun
OF Michael Bourn
OF Jayson Werth
Util Casey McGehee
BN Rickie Weeks
BN Carlos Quentin
BN Billy Butler
BN Grady Sizemore

SP Félix Hernández
SP Tommy Hanson -
RP Rafael Soriano
RP Chris Pérez
P Colby Lewis
P Jorge De La Rosa
P Andrew Bailey
P Octavio Dotel
BN Daisuke Matsuzaka
BN Aroldis Chapman
BN Colby Lewis
BN Kevin Correia
DL Huston Street
DL Kerry Wood
DL Brad Lidge

[MaudDib]

It's not a bad trade but I don't like it. Without looking at rosters it is probably about right if you want/need to land Utley. But then looking at your roster and I can't see how this would benefit you. You are already solid at 2B and you would lose at 1B. I like Butler but I think he is better served as a Util than starter.