Stanton/Santana

[triple3play]

positions aside, who will be the better major league hitter?

[tailgate13]

Tough to say but in my keeper 1 team picked both guys up as free agents. They both hit for power, but Florida at least has some bats in the lineup to protect him.

Where Cleveland is really struggling to hit as a team. Plus stanton has the chance to play everyday as an OF rather than Santana that could be in a platoon as a C.

I think I would give the edge to Stanton as having immediate impact.

[oddmanout7]

I like Stanton to put up better numbers without position taken into consideration. Even with position, I will give the slight edge to Stanton.

[tailgate13]

Just got an offer for A's closer Bailey for Stanton?

I am in dead last and trying to build for next year in a 16 team keeper league. (4 keepers per year)

Think he is worth it?

[Havok1517]

Just got an offer for A's closer Bailey for Stanton?

I am in dead last and trying to build for next year in a 16 team keeper league. (4 keepers per year)

Think he is worth it?

I say no considering the position of closer is anything but a certainty.

[Amatter32]

Just got an offer for A's closer Bailey for Stanton?

I am in dead last and trying to build for next year in a 16 team keeper league. (4 keepers per year)

Think he is worth it?

Keep Stanton. If you're in last you don't need a closer.


Without positions, I would say Stanton. With positions, I would take Santana.