give up on peavy? Whir

[casem2k2]

is it time to give up on peavy?

I just got offered james loney for peavy

do I take it and run?

[outsideoftime]

That is not enough return. Peavy had 7 K's his last start and is working hard to fix his mechanics. 180Ks are still possible.

Two more really bad starts and I'd give up on him. But if he trends a bit better each time he is worth keeping. I have him on my team too.

[soty]

I wouldnt give him up for that either. Try for a little more or just hold tight like the rest of us Peavy owners.

[saemick]

now is the time to "Buy" on Peavy IMO. I don't think he'll be nearly as dominant as he was in SD, but he definitely is not as bad as he looks. I'd hold off on trading him....especially for Loney

Mine: viewtopic.php?t=409868

[PBR Baseball]

I agree with Mick. He won't replicate numbers in SD but he has to be better than he is showing. Right?

[Juhlz]

Take Loney and run?? Haha. No. Peavy will get it together. It's not like he doesn't have a proven track record. Someone dropped him in a 14 team league of mine. Just silly.

[rukus9]

As a non-Peavy owner I would definitely look at Loney for Peavy depending on what the rest of your roster looks like.

[harold_bush]

I'd keep Peavy b/c I don't think Kemp really offers that much upside. I still think Peavy will lock in here soon.

viewtopic.php?t=410088

[TheBambino]

I think Peavy will rebound..... Anyone remember last year how AWFUL Verlander and Nolasco were for the first little while?... Then they dominated.

I think Peavy will adjust... he has awesome stuff.

What does everyone else think?