AROLDIS CHAPMAN OR JUSTIN SMOAK?

[Nuschler]

Question for you guys. I have been offered Justin Smoak for Aroldis Chapman in a keeper league. Here are the contracts:

Smoak $1- 1st year
Chapman $4-2nd year

We can keep players 3 years at the same salary.

Is Smoak's bat going to get going? Any thoughts on this one?

[mblax10]

Um, you're getting the better player for cheaper, an extra year of service and he's already in the majors.

[Montana168]

smoak for sure. i will always keep a stud hitting prospect over a stud pitching prospect.

[colby2152]

Um, you're getting the better player for cheaper, an extra year of service and he's already in the majors.

Wow, I would be all over that one.

[Nuschler]

Thanks guys, that's what I was thinking but it's always nice to get some back up. I will try get the deal done. Thanks.