I am in a 12 team H2H format. This is an auction league with a $260 cap. I just traded Matsui, Shin Coo, and Madison for K Morales & Jake Peavy. This is my team now. C. Bengie Molina 1b. Miguel Cabrera 2b. Brandon Phillips 3b. Alex Rodriguez SS. Alexi Ramirez OF. Carl Crawford OF. Matt Kemp OF. Ichiro Suzuki DH. Adrian Gonzalez P. Roy Halladay P. Ian Kennedy P John Lackey P. Jake Peavy P Ben Sheets P. Rich Harden P. Mike Pelfrey RP. Trevor Hoffman RP. Hideki Okajima (We use holds) RP. Jose Valverde RP. Madson
Bench Casey McGehee Jacoby Ellsbury Nick Swisher Jeff Francoeur Magglio Ordonez
I was just offered Reyes , Doumit & Willingham for my Kemp and Molina. I told the owner if he was to take out Willingham & add King Felix I would consider doing a deal, they want a pitcher in return I was going to say Sheets... i know Peavy has not been great I just do not see giving up Kemp and then a pitcher with a good upside help me. What do you guys think??? Please help ASAP also leave a link I will help as well. Thanks
No way. Keep what you have. You don't need Reyes... you have MCab, ARod, Crawford, Kemp, Ichiro, AGonz, and BPhil... that's stacked enough already. If anything, I would try and trade one of your OFs for a mid-tier SS (BUT NOT KEMP) so I wouldn't have a log-jam once Ellsbury returns. Or maybe try and ship an OF for an elite SP, because after Halladay and Lackey, your rotation is kind of questionable.
Yankeefan!4 wrote:I know the only reason i am entertaining the offer is because Reyes is contracted for 3 years at 27 bucks and King Felix will give me a stud pitcher I need pretty bad.
See if he'll give you Felix for Ellsbury... you might even be stacked enough to part with Crawford if he rejects Ells. As it is, you don't have enough room to play all of your top-notch OF guys. I would get rid of either Ells or Crawford, Ells first, because both players are essentially high average, SB threats, and you don't really need the both of them on your team.
A stud pitcher would certainly help a lot, but the price is too high imo. I think you are a fair way from a deal to be honest - I would only want to give up one pitcher, and preferably one without too much upside.