Need Catcher 20 Team H2H Dynasty League

[TheKid99]

My catcher got sent down today so I need some help quite a bit.

C- Ramon Hernandez (Best on FA)
1b- Carlos Pena
2b- Rickie Weeks
SS- Jason Bartett
3B- Ryan Zimmerman
OF- Matt Holliday
OF- Jason Bay
OF- Josh Willingham
Util- Carlos Gonzalez
Util- Jose Guillen
Bn- Gabby Sanchez
Bn-Angel Pagen
Bn- Chris Iannetta

SP- Derek Lowe
SP- Javier Vazquez
RP- Billy Wagner
RP- Latroy Hawkins
P- Matt Guerrier
P- Grant Balfour
P- Dan Wheeler
Bn- Scott Baker
Bn- Dallas Braden
Bn- Wade LeBlanc
Bn- Justin Duscherer
Bn- Carlos Villanueva
Bn- Scott Feldman
Bn- Carlos Silva
DL- Chris Young

So I have two trade offers for catchers.

First is Ryan Doumit for my farm hand Jaime Garcia. I'm not a huge Doumit fan and Garcia looks good.

The second deal is Victor Martinez for guys in farm system Jaime Garcia and Julio Teheran. Now if you look at my staff some of the guys are older and I like the fact that I have two guys coming up soon to my roster. The issue is I do like Victor Martinez and he would be a huge upgrade for my team. Should I try and offer one of the guys and offer something else to fill in? Or is this about as good as I can expect?

[Pokey]

I would do either trades, and you if you really like V-Mart, definitely that one. Garcia is a good but not great pitching prospect, and Teheran is so far away and such a question mark that you can't let him stop you from getting an upper-tier catcher in such a deep league. Do you really think the trade off of being stuck with hernandez over martinez now is going to be worth it in 5-7 years when Teheran might be useful?

[TheKid99]

You do make a good point. Although in a small sample Garcia sure looks good right now.