Keeper Trade: Scherzer for Vmart - WHIR

[crudbucket36]

Was just offered Vmart for Scherzer in a keeper league. I am seriously considering taking this. I don't think Scherzer can keep it up and Vmart should turn it around. I realize I have Mauer already but I see this as a great value trade. Your thoughts? WHIR.

ESPN Roto 5x5 10 team 12 keeper

My Team:

C Mauer
1B P. Fielder
2B D. Pedroia
3B M. Young
SS Jeter
MI B. Phillips
CI Votto
OF Coghlan
OF C. Lee
OF G. Jones
OF J. Guillen
OF Brett Gardner
Util Helton
BN D. Young
DL Beltran

P Jimenez
P J. Sanchez
P Cain
P Scherzer
P Jurrjens
P Dempster
P F. Cordero
P Aardsma
P J. Johnson
BN Lilly
BN Penny
DL Bedard

[wyld stallions]

I would make the trade, value wise I think Vmart is worth a lot more than Scherzer. Even though you have Mauer, you should be able to Net something worth a lot more than Scherzer in the longrun. I hate making trades to in the future trade again, but I don't think you can argue with this one.

please help me: viewtopic.php?t=409729

[crudbucket36]

Anyone else?

[sman]

I would do that deal as well as I think that Martinez would be much more valuable to you in a trade situation. It's a lot harder to find a catcher of his caliber than a pitcher of or close to Scherzer's level.

Please help with mine: viewtopic.php?t=409651

[Hamburglar07]

Make the trade. Vmart is cold but he is clearly the much better player. I have never liked Scherzer, he hardly puts up any points and the K's aren't coming.