Clay Bucholz vs Ian Kennedy

[Zain1two3]

If you had to make a choice, between these two pitchers, that were both on the waiver wire, which one would you pick up? The league I'm in has neither of these guys on WW, its a hypothetical question. My league rewards W, K and IP. I may lean towards Bucholz as there is a smaller chance that the BOSOX bullpen will blow a lead than the Arizon bullpen will (which happened for Kennedy in his last start: 8IP, 4K, ND). Comments greatly appreciated, will help with your topics too.

[Zain1two3]

Ok, I didn't give all the information in the above post so here it is...

I made a trade and here it is. Who is better off?

I received:

J.P. Arencibia
Ian Desmond
Mark Reynolds
Ian Kennedy

I traded:
Jorge Posada
Omar Vizquel
Gordon Beckham
Clay Buchholz..

[Kafka]

I would go with Bucholz.

Is it a keeper?

[Zain1two3]

not a keeper......