Who Wins This Trade?

[rasto21585]

In a 20 team dynasty league, who would you say one this trade?

team a gets miguel cabrera and either chris coghlan or franklin gutierrez

team b gets justin morneau john danks and justin smoak

[Roberto Clemente]

That is close...but in the end I would take the side that is getting M.Cabrera and I would choose F.Gutierrez.

Cabrera is a little better than Morneau.

The J.Danks or J.Smoak side could end up being better because Danks is pitching really well so far this year and Smoak could be a good young hitter. Gutierrez will always hit for high average.

[MaudDib]

That is close...but in the end I would take the side that is getting M.Cabrera and I would choose F.Gutierrez.

Cabrera is a little better than Morneau.

The J.Danks or J.Smoak side could end up being better because Danks is pitching really well so far this year and Smoak could be a good young hitter. Gutierrez will always hit for high average.

I agree with this. It is really close but A is the safer side and the better talent.

[RJHNY1]

Personally, I like side B in a dynasty league. Morneau is not a steep drop from Miggy. Danks is a good pitcher and Smoak is a very very good prospect.

Help with mine? viewtopic.php?t=409122

[rasto21585]

Ok how about this? Who wins?

team a gets miguel cabrera and chris coghlan

team b gets smoak danks and either lester or hamels