My Sizemore / E. Santana for Markakis / Liriano WHIR

[uhhhjboy]

Got burned by Sizemore last year. This year he fell in our keeper league draft until the 5th round (insane) so I had to peg him even though I didn't really want to deal with him again. My OF is pretty deep, I think, and the guy with Liriano is a fellow Angels fan. I've been hyping Santana to him since ST.

Thoughts?

12 Team League H2H 14 Cats:
R H HR RBI SB BB AVG - IP W SV K ERA WHIP K/9

C - Wieters
1B - M. Cabrera
2B - R. Weeks
3B - R. Zimmerman
SS - S. Drew
OF / Ut - M. Holliday, G. Sizemore, C. Gonzalez, J. Borbon
Bn - H. Pence, M. Ordonez, Alex Gordon

SP - A. Wainwright, U. Jimenez, R. Nolasco, J. Sanchez, E. Santana, R. Wolf, W. Davis, I. Kennedy
RP - H. Bell, C. Marmol

DL - E. Volquez

[weiselmck]

I sort of see this deal as a wash. Markakis is really struggling this year, even worse than Sizemore. Liriano has been awesome but it's still early and his injury risk has to be taken into account. For me its Sizemore>Markakis and Liriano>Santana. So you have to decide whether you want the better SP or the better OF. I would stay put if it was up to me, depends on how much you like Liriano.

[RJHNY1]

I would stay put. Your pitching is strong enough. Stay with the better OF.

Help with mine? viewtopic.php?t=409122

[NWilli]

Markakis>Sizemore. I don't know who I like more between Santana and Liriano, but Liriano's off too the better start. If you like Liriano more, I see you improving in both positions. Go for it.

viewtopic.php?t=409136

[Bip Roberts]

stay put dude