Smoak or Ike Davis? WHIR

[espnsportsfan]

Which top 1b prospect would you rather have on you squad, Smoak or Ike Davis?

10 team 5x5 roto

[saemick]

in a 10-team if it's not a keeper, I'd probably not pick up either, but if it IS a keeper, definitely Smoak. He's been raking in the minors for a while now, and I think will have the better year(s)...+ he's hitting in Texas.

my vote is for Smoak

please help:

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=409062

[soty]

Wow havent seen that sig in a while. I think I made that one for a contest? Anyways I would take Smoak. From what I have read he is a much more polished hitter and plays in Texas.

[espnsportsfan]

ya, I've been off the Cafe a bit recently, you told me i could use it like a year ago...its a keeper, sorry to not post that

I was feeling Smoak too...who would you guys consider cutting
C-Olivo
C-Snyder
1b-Butler
2nd-Utley
SS-alex gonzalez
3b-longoria
mi-phillips
ci-mcgehee
of-bay, hamilton, sizemore, werth, C young
util-francouer
bench-Rollins, Ellsbury

P-Hamels, Lackey, Baker, Romero, Pelfrey, Floyd, Liriano
RP-Papelbon, Gregg
Bench-Carmona, Matusz, Kazmir, Lilly, Bailey

[saemick]

you have a pretty solid team, but I'd consider dropping either McGehee or even Carmona.

I noticed you have 2 C's listed, so i assume you need to start 2...but if you don't, there's who you drop.

thanks for the help with mine too...I added a question, so if you could take another look, I'd appreciate it:

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=409062

thanks