Carlos Silva...or Jaime Garcia??

[Auronx62]

in a 9 man 5x5 roto league, looking to see which pitcher to pickup/stash

I currently have garcia starting tonight, but was wondering if i should drop for carlos silva who is on waiver wire. Both have posted good numbers with silva slightly edging garcia out, but i'm taking the overall team into consideration. (runs support and such). just looking purely at a pitching perspective, who in your opinion should be picked up?

if i dont drop garcia, whom from this list of pitchers should i drop?
Kazmir, Marcum, or S feldman.

Thanx.

[smoovethug]

Garcia all the way. I fear it won't be long before Silva turns back into a pumpkin. Plus he's FAT.

[PandaPack]

Not sure I'd start him against Lincecum, but that's just me.

[jackie hayes]

I wouldn't drop any of those guys for Silva. I wouldn't even touch him in an NL-only league, let alone a mixed league with 9 teams. Leave him on the wire and forget about him.

[soty]

Keep Garcia.

[WaCougMBS]

Just wanted to let you know we addressed your question specifically on the Cafe's fantasy baseball podcast, The Can of Corn, which aired this afternoon on Fantasy Baseball Cafe Radio - give 'er a listen and you'll get some answers! Hope we can help

Here's the link for the show if you're interested: http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/radio.php