Trade Help Needed! WHIR 100%

[Urban Cohorts]

12 Team, 5x5 Yahoo League, 8 Keepers (any), Standard Positions plus CI, MI, OF (we also use LF/CF/RF instead of 3xOF)

Was offered M Reynolds 3B and G Floyd SP for my CF Curtis Granderson and SP Josh Johnson
I also get a 4th round pick for a 6th round pick in 2011

Granderson will be replaced by C Beltran/Cameron Maybin
Reynolds will be replacing A Gordon / S Rolen at 3B OR replacing D Barton / M Laporta at 1B

My SP is stacked already (Wainwright, Matusz, Strasburg, Hammell, Billingsley, Slowey)
My OF is very loaded (Granderson, Beltran, Werth, Maybin, Crawford

Fair trade? Help would be VERY appreciated!!! WHIR 100%!!!

[CubsFan4Life23]

I think it's fair IMO...I'd rather deal Weth over granderson though, but just bc I dont like werth. I also hate the yanks, so it's your call. I think its a fair deal

[sha]

the picks will be nice but i think you are giving up too much. Beltran is far from being a sure fire stud in my book, i wouldn't do this deal. Werth instead of Granderson is a good argument, though. thanks for helping!

[PapelbonBLEWit]

I would stand pat.... depending on how you value those draft picks. Gavin Floyd is very overrated IMO. Maybin is unproven and it looks like Beltran wont be back until the ASB.