Need a quick answer.... 4 big names involved!!! WHIR

[PapelbonBLEWit]

10 team 5X5 Roto keeper where we keep 5 after each season.

I have been offered Jose Reyes and Yovanni Gallardo FOR Bay and Kendry Morales.

I can insert Reyes in at MI and acquire another top 15 pitcher that my staff needs. Risky on the Reyes end but Bay could also be a risk..... What do you guys think about this? Leave a link and I'd be happy to help you out. I specialize in 5X5 Roto leagues. Thanks again!


C: Russ Martin
1B: Prince
1B: Fielder
2B: Adsrubal Cabrera
3B: Wright
SS: Yunel Escobar
MI: Kinsler (DL)
CI: Chase Headley
OF: Holliday
OF: Bay
OF: Hamilton
OF: Ludwick
OF: Byrd
Util: Kendry Morales
P: Nolasco
P: Kershaw
P: Baker
P: Slowey
P: Hughes
P: Pelfrey
P: Lilly
P: Ben Sheets
P: Colby Lewis
P: K-Rod
P: F. Morales
P: Jim Johnson
P: Kevin Gregg
P: Matt Thornton
Bench: Delmon and Ike David
DL: Webb

[jdramirez1314]

That's a lot of offense to get rid of, especially with a ? in reyes with his thyroid condition. I would look elsewhere if youre going to trade that much power. I like Gallardo, but I don't think he's worth giving up possibly 60 HR and around 180 RBI.

viewtopic.php?t=408856 mine

[Urban Cohorts]

I agree with the above poster. I would stick with what you have until Reyes status becomes more predictable.

viewtopic.php?t=408859

[sha]

i don;t think bay is much of a risk...could be underrated infact. reyes is big question mark and i do like morales. stay put, man! thanks for the help!

[PapelbonBLEWit]

Thanks for the help guys but I just dealt Russ Martin and Kevin Gregg for Carlos Lee. Great buy low I hope. That should make up for the loss of Bay's power. I think Bay and Lee will have very similar years. I think I am going to go ahead and make the Reyes deal now because of this trade. Any thoughts before I pull the trigger?

[PapelbonBLEWit]

bump

[guyincognito]

I have to agree with everyone here, I would keep what you have. I love Gallardo, but out of the four guys mentioned, Reyes is the biggest risk. I agree with the other poster that I think Bay will be fine. Keep what you have.

Help me?: viewtopic.php?f=26&t=408950

[hartmtown]

I disagree with everyone. I'd definitely do the Reyes deal. He's going to be fine and Gallardo is a great pitcher to have. Nice work.

[eviljoshing]

As it's a keeper, I'd do the deal. I think even if Reyes isn't 100% this year, he will be next year and then you are killing it with this deal. I also have 0 faith in bay. Help?

viewtopic.php?t=408985