Big Z to the pen! Now who to add? WHIR

[sha]

With the move of Carlos Zambrano to the bullpen, i feel like i need to make a move. We don't carry a bench so i pretty much have to drop him (maybe if he goes back to the rotation i can get him back). Available arms on the WW inlclude: Pelfrey, Pineiro, Marcum, Jaime Garcia. We get 12 pts for a W and 1 pt per K, 5 pts for CGs and SHOs. I am leaning toward Pelfrey right now. Pineiro is a nice possibility too. I am not too thrilled with the idea of adding Garcia with him possibly getting skipped in the rotation from time to time. who do i add! i'm assuming zambrano will be in the pen for a while so probably not worth burning the roster spot.
Once again options are:
Pelfrey
Pineiro
Marcu
Garcia

[pibb55]

This sounds short term so I'd like at these pitchers next four or five matchups

I dont like Piniero's (NYY, DET, BOS, TB)
Marcums isnt much better (BOS, OAK, CWS, BOS)
Pelfreys is so-so (ATL, PHI, SF, WASH)
Garcia (SF, ATL, PHI, PIT)

In a standard league Id say hold on to Big Z but not when Wins are 12 pts.

Id rank them
Pelfrey
Marcum
Piniero
Garcia

[Rhinochasers]

I would have them in the same order
Pelfrey
Marcum
Piniero
Garcia

Pelfrey is on fire right now. I like Marcum just have to watch him against Yankees and maybe TB

[PapelbonBLEWit]

Take Pelfrey. Pitching in a pitchers park, he has always had a plus fastball/sinker, he just needed to command and develop his secondary pitches. He has started throwing a nasty splitter and is mixing in a curveball as well. These secondary pitches will also add to his K numbers. He could win 15 games....

What do you think of this deal? Thanks in advance!

viewtopic.php?t=408855

[Urban Cohorts]

Gotta agree with the above posters. Pelfrey would be my guy. If wins weren't weighed as strongly, I would be tempted to go with Marcum.

viewtopic.php?t=408859