Opinions on 3 BIG trade options? WHIR

[fan of the cubs]

Are they fair? Who wins?

1. C. Quentin, P. Fielder, R. Martin for V. Martinez, M. Teixeira


2. P. Fielder, R. Martin, S. Choo, M. Cain for V. Martinez, M. Teixeira, H. Pence


3. R. Zimmerman, J. Valverde for D. Haren, K. Johnson


H2H standard scoring, can post rosters if necessary.

[rukus9]

First one is a little lopsided in favor of the Quentin side. Second one is pretty even. Third one very slightly favors Zimmerman side.

Help? http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=408716

[fan of the cubs]

they are all reasonable trades then correct?

[rukus9]

I think the first would would be much more fair without Martin. Would then be slight edge to the Tex side.