Trade, Josh Hamilton for Grady Sizemore H2H

[ragnarok83]

Hello,

I am a commissioner of a league and was wondering if Josh Hamilton for Grady Sizemore was a fair trade. I bring this up because a few members of the league feel it is not a fair deal so I figured I would post here to find out. Instead of having 5v5 categories, there is one extra for hitting (TB) and pitching (QS). Any help would be appreciated!

Team A

C Joe Mauer
1B Mark Teixeira
2B Brandon Phillips
3B Pablo Sandoval
SS Ben Zobrist
OF Jason Bay
OF Josh Hamilton
OF Josh Willingham
Util Hunter Pence
BN Scott Podsednik

Team B:

C Chris Snyder
1B Garrett Jones
2B Martín Prado
3B Álex Rodríguez
SS Álex González
OF Juan Pierre
OF Justin Upton
OF Austin Jackson
Util Jason Heyward
BN Grady Sizemore