Drop Coghlan or Reimold in dynasty

[Green Bastard]

I want to pick up Ike Davis who doesn't appear to be on anyone's farm team. Manny is my full time left fielder, and Nolan Reimold and Chris Coghlan haven't done enough this season to even get up off my bench, so I'm going to cut one. I have to think Coghlan has to have the most upside as the O's won't even give Reimold a full time gig. Even with Pie on the DL it's been announced that he'll platoon with Lou Montanez now. This league uses basic offensive categories with OPS added.

[GamerJOW]

I have both in my keeper league, as well. I would agree that Coghlan is a better choice to keep than Reimold; he's the regular starter and has a strong rookie season to indicate his potential as a 20/20 player even this year once he figures his swing out. Reimold may - perhaps - get a slightly higher SLG to help with OPS, but with fewer ABs and less speed, as well as a less speed-oriented offense.