Maybin or Coghlan? WHIR

[Bosny]

Coghlan had all the pre-season hype but Maybin seems to be putting up better numbers and just took the leadoff spot from Coghlan. Is it too early to judge Coghlan as a bust after such high hopes? Which one shoudl I be investing in? Other free agents available are:
willingham
stewart
rivera'
matsui
c. young
Are these better options? Thanks in advance.

[PinStripe Pride 718]

willingham-5
stewart-1
rivera'-2
matsui-3
c. young-4
are all better options too me

here is mine if u can help

viewtopic.php?t=408316