Flip a coin? I've been offered Garza for Anderson WHIR

[Bonger]

10 team H2H points league with deep benches, we keep 6 at no penalty. We start 5 starters and one closer.

So, I got offered Garza for Brett Anderson straight up. I'm thinking of turning it down, I don't see how it makes me better, or worse for that matter. Thoughts?

My starters:

Hamels
Nolasco
Anderson
Danks
Price
Liriano
Kazmir
J. Sanchez
Harang
Bailey
Saunders
Carmona
Masterson

P.S. Start Sanchez at SD, Noasco @ CO or Liriano vs CLE next week?

[ChainDrive]

i think your gonna get more out of garza imo

help? viewtopic.php?t=408308

[garf112]

yeah, can't say that I really understand this trade.

I had Anderson slightly ranked higher for this year. Anderson has a higher ceiling and the lower floor. If you are looking for a consistent good ERA, WHIP, K's and probably more wins, go with Garza. Did you draft Anderson ahead of Garza?

[Bonger]

I did. Anderson went one round ahead of Garza. Good point, I did pay for Anderson's upside, didn't I. I guess Garza's hot start is getting to me...I should know better than to be getting cold feet already,

[PinStripe Pride 718]

i say stay with what u got ad go with liriano 4 sure

here is mine

viewtopic.php?t=408316