Trade Help! WHIR

[captain num nuts]

I'm in a H2H points league. I'm thinking of offering my Adam Jones and Asdrubal Cabrera for his Stephen Drew and Prado. I need SS help. Am I giving up to much. I really like Jones and hate to get rid of him. Should I wait till Coghlan starts playing better and Carlos Gonzalez comes back and use them in a trade and keep Jones. I always WHIR, so leave my your question.

[captain num nuts]

bump

[Rhinochasers]

I would make the trade if you need SS help. Drew looks like he might break out and CarGo's stats will be near Jones at the end of the year.

[Dr. Whom]

I would make that trade for the slight upgrade at SS and you will also get Prado


Can you help here?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=408197

[Urban Cohorts]

I would offer this deal.

I like Drew + Prado more than Jones + Cabrera. I think Drew is going to have a fine year, at least equal to that of Adam Jones (in truth, I think both could have monster years, but I see this being more likely with Drew). Plus, it's a lot easier to add another OF than a SS, which is also in your favor. I like Prado and hate Cabrera. Can't really say why, just not that impressed by Cabrera.

Hope this helps!

viewtopic.php?t=408198

[coma]

Tough call, as I think Jones is the best player in the deal. If you are desperate for SS help though, I'd pull the trigger.

[jeffh]

Tough trade, think it depends how desperate you are. Personally, I don't like this trade for you and would reject. If you are really desperate at short and fairly deep in OF, that might change things a bit, but I'd find a way to get a little more value as I don't love either of the guys you're getting (I like Prado but think both are a little overvaulued). Thanks for the help with mine.