sizemore, hanson for pierre, halladay WHIR

[fierro33]

5 player keeper league 12 team roto


i do need some more sbs and help with pitching

would u give up sizemore and hanson for pierre and halladay? not sure giving up hanson is very wise

C Mauer
1b Prince
2b Jose Lopez
3b Zimmerman
ss Aybar
2b/ss Kelly Johnson
1b/3b Prado
of Braun
of Justin Upton
of Sizemore
of Rios
of Magglio
Util Willingham
Tejada
Alex Gordon

Hanson
Nolasco
Garza
Webb
Jonathon Sanchez
Justin Duch
Dice-K
Bedard DL
Carmona

Rauch
Bell
Jenks
Dotel

[Slayer Rules]

No - Sizemore has health issues, yes - but if your purpose in doing this is acquiring more SBs this really doesn't make a lot of sense for you. Sizemore steals 25-30 bases when he's healthy - Pierre's going to get you maybe 5-10 more per year while getting 20+ fewer HRs?. Sizemore's also 5 yrs younger than Pierre - this really would be a horrible deal for you.

Halladay's the better pitcher than Hanson "right now" - but that gap is closing and soon enough the tables will turn.

[Padres Fan]

No - Sizemore has health issues, yes - but if your purpose in doing this is acquiring more SBs this really doesn't make a lot of sense for you. Sizemore steals 25-30 bases when he's healthy - Pierre's going to get you maybe 5-10 more per year while getting 20+ fewer HRs?. Sizemore's also 5 yrs younger than Pierre - this really would be a horrible deal for you.

Halladay's the better pitcher than Hanson "right now" - but that gap is closing and soon enough the tables will turn.

help with mine?
viewtopic.php?t=408130

[thejusman1]

That looks like a pretty awful trade. I would stand pat.