Should I accept this trade?

[kjcasey42]

Okay, guy's offering me Jared Weaver and Chase Headley in exchange for I-Rod, Jorge Cantu, and Octavio Dotel. I could definitely use Weaver, and I-Rod is my backup so that's not really a big deal. But I am really hesitant about trading Cantu for Headley. What are your thoughts on this?

[tailgate13]

I have Headley and he is hitting for average but has not shown any HR pop yet. His OF/3b option is nice to have during the week when shuffling the line up though. I think I would hold off on this trade or counter with Dotel & Irod for Weaver straight up.

[ddog5843]

I've got Cantu. No way I'm letting go of that bat right now.

[dagactor]

Cantu hits more HR. Simple fact.