Catcher question! Which one? WHIR!

[Brizee8]

Here's my dilemna: Mike Napoli is my only catcher, but he seems to have drawn the wrath of Scioscia and almost never plays. I'm trying to figure out if I should drop him and pick up a free agent (there aren't many).

Here are the catchers available:
Ivan Rodriguez
Miguel Olivo
Chris Snyder
Jeff Mathis
Jason Kendall
John Baker
John Buck

I know it's slim pickins. Are any of those worth dropping Napoli for?

[RedBirdChica]

Pick up Pudge for now. He's surging and so are the Nats.

If he starts to slump, drop him like a rock and go for Snyder (who HAS a recent history of being fantasy relevant)

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=407998

[jackie hayes]

I'd wait it out with Napoli. Too potent a bat to give up on this early.

[dssguy99]

There seems to be some good catchers out there...I would get Pudge. If napoli is not playing he is loosing you points right now.

[amarlls]

Ya for sure Pudge right now

viewtopic.php?t=408009

[zechs]

Basically, if you have room for Pudge or some scrub worth dropping for him then go ahead and make the move.

If you are in a roto league, you will want to bench Napoli then and start another catcher. But if you are in a head-to-head league, you may as well stick with starting Napoli and pray.

I still think it is too early in the season to give up on Napoli, however.

Please help me out with mine? viewtopic.php?t=408013