My Tulo and Hamels for MCab and Cliff Lee? WHIR

[abrage22]

Would this trade help my team??

C- McCann
1- Butler
2- Cano
SS- Tulowitzki
3- Zimmerman
CI- Ad. LaRoche
MI- M. Prado
OF-Adam Jones
OF- Braun
OF- Bruce
OF- BJ Upton
DH- Guerrero

SP- Wainwright
SP- Hamels
SP- Nolasco
SP- Hanson
SP- Scherzer
RP- Soria
RP- Qualls

B- Webb
B- Happ
B- M. Laporta
B- Aybar
B- McGehee
B- J. Francour
B- C. Davis

[Grounded Polo]

I'd make the deal, Lee is better than Hamels but still injured so it's close. Miggy is definitely who I'd want over Tulo.

[jdip5]

id do the deal. The deal is pretty even but id definately prefer mcab over tulo. Lee will finish better then hamels, even with his DL stint. Im a phils fan, and a hamels owner, but im not too confident in hamels this year. He seems the hamels of last year, and not of 2008. I like this for you
HELP?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=407895