Ok so first things first, what happens when you have 2 players with first round value? Cuz I'm guessing Miggy is available to keep for 1st round value, or are you even aloud to keep him?
Value wise I would take Miggy 9 out of 10 times. Also looking at your roster you have to do this deal, Davis/Pence/Phillips should give you enough speed to hold you over, and starting Prado at 1B is killing you. Id do the deal, move Dunn to the OF and platoon Davis/Hawpe/Jackson at UTIL, why is Pronk even rostered? There has to be better value on the FA list then Hafner. List your available FAs, and take the deal.
Help me out...viewtopic.php?t=407819