Need an SP if B.H. Kim is down

[BobbyRoberto]

12 team league, Roto
Pitching categories: W, SVS, K, ERA, WHIP, W%

My 6 SP's:
Schilling
Hudson
Santana
Clement
Edw. Jackson
B.H. Kim

Kim looks like he might be down until mid-April. Who do I get pick up out of the following, considering my categories and the pitchers I already have? I've narrowed it down to these 5:

Carl Pavano
Jeremy Affeldt
Tim Redding
Wilson Alvarez
Brian Lawrence

Any help? Top-3 rank?

[twentysix]

you might just want to pick up Kim's replacement, Bronson Arroyo. He's got nasty stuff. It depends on who you'd have to drop to pick him up. You may want a replacement that's a full-time starter somewhere else, instead of your injured guy's temporary replacement.

just a thought

[Pedantic]

Lawrence
Affeldt
Redding

[BobbyRoberto]

twentysix wrote:

you might just want to pick up Kim's replacement, Bronson Arroyo. He's got nasty stuff. It depends on who you'd have to drop to pick him up. You may want a replacement that's a full-time starter somewhere else, instead of your injured guy's temporary replacement.

just a thought

I was thinking about doing that also. In this league, when someone goes on the DL, you get a replacement, so I wouldn't have to drop anyone. I could just swap Kim for Arroyo and when Kim is healthy, I could choose between them.

[ondeckb]

Arroyo is good...Affeldt is better....

[Transmogrifier]

How is Lawrence not on a team?

[BobbyRoberto]

Lawrence slipped through the draft. He's been getting rocked this spring:

13.1 inn, 28 h, 15 er, 8 k, 7 bb, 10.13 ERA

I don't usually put any stock in spring training stats but 35 baserunners in 13.1 innings is really ugly.

[bsdo4ever]

Brett Myers or Eric Milton. The phillies are back

[DGroundhog]

Affeldt or Redding.

[polyphonic]

Eric Milton has never been a good pitcher, why would he start now?