Trade Hanley and Uggla for Utley and Josh Johnson? WHIR

[money]

I'm in an 8 team yahoo head to head league with standard scoring. I had someone offer me Utley for Hanley. Should I counter with Hanley + Uggla for Utley and another player? Another team has Pedroia and Phillips and I was maybe thinking about trying to get Phillips from him instead too.

My team:

C: Victor Martinez
1B: Adrian Gonzalez
2B: Dan Uggla
SS: Hanley Ramirez (keeper)
3B: Alex Rodriguez (keeper)
OF: Matt Kemp
OF: Nelson Cruz
OF: Manny Ramirez
Util: Justin Morneau

bench:
Jose Reyes
Josh Hamilton
Rajai Davis

SP: Matt Garza
SP: Chad Billingsley
RP: Jonathon Broxton
RP: Francicsco Rodriguez
P: Jon Rauch
P: Ricky Romero
P: Max Scherzer

Bench:
Carlos Zambrano
James Shields
Shawn Marcum (might cut him for a SP too)

DL: Cliff Lee
DL: Brandon Webb

His team:

C: Molina
1B: Reynolds
2B: Utley
SS: Bartlett
3B: Zimmerman
OF: Bay
OF: Ibanez
OF: Abreau
Util: Orlando Cabrera

bench:
Bourn

DL:
Berkman

SP: Greinke
SP: Halladay
RP: Fuentes
RP: Bell
P: Hoffman
P: Jered Weaver
P: Arroyo

bench:
De La Rosa
Josh Johnson
Brad Penny
Piniero
Strasburg

[money]

Any suggestions? I'm leaning more towards trying to package Hanley and Uggla for Utley and Josh Johnson.

[miller24x]

What the hell? Hanley is a Top 2 player. Don't trade him!

[cws5887]

No doubt! Are you smoking today? You must be a Philly fan!

[money]

No doubt! Are you smoking today? You must be a Philly fan!

I'm not, but did you see that I have Reyes sitting on the bench and Utley is a top 5 player anyway. I might try to package Hanley and one of my 1b for Pujols instead of doing the Utley trade.

[Swagger]

i would keep hanley and trades Reyes....maybe for an upgrade at 2nd or a pitcher....you don't really need pujols with agonz on your team....keep hanley is pretty much the bottom line and trade reyes

[JeepCop]

I would do this trade if you KNEW Reyes was going to return to form. I wouldn't worry too much about AGon because I think he'll be solid by years end. Just look at this infield potential:

AGon, Utley, Reyes, ARod

That's quite the squad you'd have there!!!


Lil help?
viewtopic.php?t=407885

[miller24x]

Trade Reyes instead of Hanley

AGon, Sack of Garbage, Reyes, ARod, Hanley (UTIL)

is the best fantasy team you'll ever see.

[cws5887]

I would get rid of Reyes ASAP, before he shows how much he has lost! He is going to have problems all year. Hanley is a stud!

[eric31216]

to move hanley, i would need to be overwhelmed. utley and johnson are nice, but you can get much much better... especially in a keeper


help? viewtopic.php?t=407838